David Miliband is being painted as both traitor and loser after Patricia Hewitt and Geoff Hoon’s failed putsch to oust Gordon Brown, yet his actions – by accident or design – have strengthened his cause.
Miliband’s failure to come out in support of the rebels, as one of the alleged cabinet ministers in support of the ’secret ballot’, could be seen as a bit of a missed opportunity. He could’ve taken the leadership of the Labour party without Brown’s blood on his hands, Hoon and Hewitt having fired the initial shots.
Yet in taking the leadership, the current foreign secretary risked taking a bullet from a potentially triumphant Tory election campaign. He would perhaps put up more of a fight than Brown, though he could arguably do very little to prevent the inevitable. A leader presiding over election defeat rarely recovers political clout.
Milliband’s failure to ride to the aid of the Prime Minister until the eleventh hour has supposedly left him weakened too. His hesitency has been interpreted as uncertainty and clumsiness. It is likely that he was considering whether to act, seen as a sure sign of weakness by many.
We may never know the reasoning behind Miliband’s position, yet the whole debacle has inevitably strenghtened him, regardless of his intentions.
His slow response has perhaps weakened him in the immediate present. His lackluster support for Brown could be sign of a hidden rift that could harm Labour’s election campaign. Yet the situation has reminded us that he is in the running to lead in future and that his name ought to be top of the list when the time is right.
The speed with which each cabinet minister issued statements of support for Gordon Brown on Wednesday did tally with loyalty, yet the longer we waited, the more the sense of anticipation for Milliband’s reaction grew. Was he to become leader? Or was he to remain loyal – keeping his powder dry?
As it was, he chose the latter. In the face of so many cabinet statements of support, he was left with little choice; it could have been a different story if no one had come to Brown’s aid earlier. Ultimately however, as the last cabinet member to come out in support of the Prime Minister, Miliband has assumed the position of being key.
In May last year, Alan Johnson was the dead-on cert to take over as Labour leader in the event of Gordon Brown’s political demise. No more.
The failed Hoon/Hewitt putsch has seen the importance of David Miliband return to the fore.
On the first day of Christmas, my MP bought on behalf of me …
Democracy is reaching new highs on the internet, as the Guardian has decided to open up one of its investigations to the public via Twitter and its website.
‘Labour Party politics had become a variant of Conservatism, ‘revolutionary’ politics had become a game of make-believe.’
Today has mainly featured me falling asleep in uncomfortable places, capped off by the bliss of a bunk bed; a rarified object which I haven’t seen for almost a week now.
I’m now away on what is gradually becoming a yearly ritual. Me and my good friend Alex Hope have yet again hit the rails of Europe in search of sun, sea, music, alcohol, culture and much more.
Today I was in my work guise for the British Chambers of Commerce (BCC) annual convention, at the International Convention Centre (ICC) Birmingham.